Lion Cub-Petting Study Finds Alarming Welfare Concerns in Animal Tourism Industry
First-of-its-kind study, published in Animals, analyzes YouTube videos to substantiate stress behaviors from lion cubs handled by tourists seeking the “Simba effect”
BOSTON, MA – OCTOBER 27, 2022 – Just in time for National Cat Day on October 29, new research on a popular wildlife tourist attraction known as "cub-petting" reveals the practice has negative welfare consequences for big cats. According to a new study led by New York University and FOUR PAWS, cub-petting normalizes touching young lions, perpetuates captive breeding, and has dire implications for the African lion species.
Published in the Special Tenth Anniversary Issue of Animals, the study addresses the problem of cub-petting tourism and the harm it inflicts on lions. Cub-petting (and cuddling) is a term for the practice of using young animals, mainly big cats like lions and tigers, as play toys and/or photo props for paying customers. To address the question of cub welfare at cub‐petting facilities in South Africa, researchers analyzed public tourist videos on YouTube to gain information about animal behavior, husbandry practices, and captive living conditions that are difficult to otherwise record.
As with other forms of tourism, “selfie” culture abounds in cub-petting and social media provides a unique source of animal behavior and welfare data. Through analysis of 267 videos, the researchers narrowed down a 49-video database of tourist-lion interactions at cub facilities. An estimated 61% of cubs were under 3 months old; two videos show cubs as young as 9 days old and 1 day old, with their eyes still shut. The mother lion was apparent in only 1 of 49 videos. In this industry, cubs on display are frequently separated from their mothers and forced to interact beyond the species’ normal waking hours. Researchers found cubs regularly exhibited stress behaviors, including avoidance and aggression.
“Our findings show that cub-petting facilities may cater to people with good intentions for the lions, but there are still grave welfare concerns,” says co-author Dr. Becca Franks. "Lions who begin their lives in such facilities become part of a larger cycle of harm including the canned hunting industry, the exotic pet trade, and the black market for wildlife parts. While these activities are well-known, the exploitation of cubs at tourist attractions is less well understood.”
Franks is Assistant Professor of Environmental Studies and Co-Director of the new NYU Wild Animal Welfare Program, which seeks to advance understanding of wild animals and how humans can improve our interactions with them. Co-authors include two recent NYU Animal Studies and Environmental Studies graduates, as well as staff from the U.S. Office of FOUR PAWS International, the global animal welfare organization. A behavior expert at LIONSROCK, a FOUR PAWS big cat sanctuary in South Africa, evaluated the videos and methodology for accuracy, reliability, and welfare assessments.
The study concludes that cub-petting facilities perpetuate harm to young lions, normalize the touching of lions, and propagate captive breeding. These issues have implications not only for the captive lion industry in South Africa but for the overall welfare and conservation of a species.
“As travel continues to rebound, tourists may seek out immersive animal experiences," says co-author Saryn Chorney, a recent graduate of the NYU Animal Studies program and journalist who writes about animals, human health, and cultural sustainability. "The so-called ‘Simba effect,’ named for a popular character from The Lion King, is a term used to describe the tourist pastime of holding or petting lion cubs while taking selfies and videos to post on social media. Before visiting LIONSROCK, I was unaware of the lion farming industry and the role cubs play as a first stage in the commodification cycle of big cats.”
The IUCN Red List classifies African lions as a vulnerable species, and lions are also listed as a threatened species under the U.S. Endangered Species Act. The African lion population has plummeted from approximately 75,000 to 30,000 wild individuals in the past 20 years. Currently, there are likely more lions in captivity (breeding farms, safari parks, zoos) than living freely in the wild. Although lions once roamed Europe, the Middle East, India, and Africa, they now live on less than 25% of their original historical range. It is estimated that lions are bred on some 300 farms for trophy hunting purposes in South Africa, and cub-petting is an integral part of this economy.
This study brings light to questions surrounding cub facilities – where the cubs originate, how they are treated and housed, and what happens to them after they become too large to interact with tourists – as welfare concerns throughout the captive lion life cycle. FOUR PAWS believes these wild animals suffer under inadequate keeping conditions from lack of expert care, frequent traveling, training, and/or intensive and forced interaction with humans. This is why the organization works to end the commercial use and trade of big cats around the world, which includes the practices of private keeping and captive breeding, trophy hunting, and cub-petting.
“This study is particularly timely,” explained co-author Claire LaFrance from FOUR PAWS International. “We are seeing these kinds of interactive activities with wild animals prove dangerous for both humans and big cats. In the past few years however, we have seen positive progress towards ending the cycle of cub abuse as demonstrated by the fall of some exploitative facilities such as Joe Exotic's (The Tiger King) in the U.S.”
As wildlife interactions relate to the global pandemic, unnecessary and inappropriate contact with wild animals, inclusive of tourist attractions such as cub-petting, is a dangerous aspect of modern life that ought to be left in the past.
The study titled Poor Welfare Indicators and Husbandry Practices at Lion (Panthera Leo) “Cub-Petting” Facilities: Evidence from Public YouTube Videos can be found here https://www.mdpi.com/1884130
Animals is an international, peer-reviewed, open-access journal devoted entirely to animals, including zoology and veterinary sciences, published semimonthly online by MDPI.
NYU Animal Studies, active since 2010 and housed in the NYU Department of Environmental Studies, is a central gathering place for people who work on topics concerning nonhuman animals. Our students work with leading scholars in Animal Studies, Environmental Studies, and related fields; participate in intensive seminars, workshops, and conferences; and engage in a wide range of theoretical, practical, and creative pursuits upon graduation.
FOUR PAWS is the global animal welfare organization for animals under direct human influence, which reveals suffering, rescues animals in need, and protects them. Founded in 1988 in Vienna by Heli Dungler and friends, the organization advocates for a world where humans treat animals with respect, empathy, and understanding. FOUR PAWS’ sustainable campaigns and projects focus on companion animals including stray dogs and cats, farm animals and wild animals – such as bears, big cats, and orangutans – kept in inappropriate conditions as well as in disaster and conflict zones. With offices in Australia, Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, France, Germany, Kosovo, the Netherlands, Switzerland, South Africa, Thailand, Ukraine, the UK, the USA and Vietnam, as well as sanctuaries for rescued animals in eleven countries, FOUR PAWS provides rapid help and long-term solutions. www.fourpawsusa.org